Identifying the First Printing of The Killing Joke

Identifying a first printing of The Killing Joke requires attention to several details, as the comic has been reprinted many times since 1988.

First Printing Markers

• Publication date: March 1988
• Format: Prestige format, square-bound, 48 pages
• Coloring: The original 1988 coloring by John Higgins uses a more vivid, garish palette than Brian Bolland preferred. This coloring is the identifier for first printings.
• Price: Original US cover price ($3.50)
• Copyright page: Check for first printing statement

The Deluxe Edition (2008)

Brian Bolland’s recolored “Deluxe Edition” (2008) features a completely different color palette — more muted and naturalistic than the 1988 original. This is NOT a first printing despite being Bolland’s preferred version. It is a separate edition with its own collectibility.

Common Pitfalls

• Confusing the 2008 Deluxe Edition with the 1988 first printing based on the hardcover format
• Accepting later printings as firsts (the prestige format has been reprinted dozens of times)
• Overlooking condition issues — prestige format comics are susceptible to spine stress and corner wear

Condition Priorities

Near-mint condition is paramount for Killing Joke values. The card stock covers show handling marks easily, and the square binding is vulnerable to spine creases. A true 9.8 CGC-graded copy commands significant premiums.